not what it used to be!. we have a condo just down the road from fisherman's corner, and we have frequented this establishment since it opened. we were celebrating my wife's birthday, so we saved this restaurant for her actual birthday, as we were expecting this to the pinnacle of our culinary experience. we were sorely disappointed!
we placed our names on the waiting list and were quoted 45 minutes for a table. that's right around the break-even time where it doesn't make sense to load up our two-year-old, choose a new restaurant, travel there and most likely have a wait at the new restaurant as well. one our and forty minutes later we finally got our table, after being told repeatedly "we were next."
since we had plenty of time to review the menu while waiting, we placed our order when our waitress first approached our table. two of our three meals came with salads which they forgot to bring out before the main course as they said they would do.
the main courses we ordered were the seafood platter with grilled oysters and some sort of whitefish. there was so much pepper on the meal you couldn't decipher any other flavor. wanting something that should have been good and easy, i ordered the fried seafood platter with shrimp and fish. i don't expect much from fried seafood, yet this meal was still disappointing. the shrimp was okay, but the fish had absolutely no flavor. we ordered the chicken fingers for my daughter as that's supposed to be a staple that's hard to mess up, yet they found a way to remove any semblance of flavor from both the chicken and the batter.
their signature dish, the shrimp and grits, was also not what it used to be. my wife thought she tasted sterno in the dish, and after all of their other failures with our dining experience, it wouldn't surprise me.
one of the main reasons my wife wanted to dine here was for their bread pudding dessert, yet they ran out of that very early in the evening. our waitress said they only made 25 of them, and they were gone sometime after lunch and before the dinner rush. they were also out of the only other dessert dish they offered. why couldn't they go next door to publix and buy some ice cream and cake so they'd have at least something to offer?
fisherman's corner could stand to learn the art of under-promising and over-delivering instead of the other way around. we enjoyed many good meals on the "key," and i'm sorry to say this wasn't one of them.
i mean no malice towards this restaurant. i only ope they can learn from our feedback and return to the sort of place they were when they opened.