sadly underwhelmed. i'd been looking forward to my trip to alloy for weeks and after saving up the cash, we went on january 9th at 830pm for an all out food and wine fest.
so disappointing.
the room is fabulous, and was full, which lent a nice buzz to the air. unfortunately that air was filled with the smell of stale fish. it was the first thing we noticed when we walked in and was quite off putting.
we started with the lobster ravioli and the crab cakes. the ravioli was served in a mango cream sauce, that was heavy on the cream and had long slivers of raw under ripe mango that could not be cut floating in it. as for the lobster, i'm not sure if it was or not-it was so processed and mushy it was hard to tell. the crab cake suffered the same fate-crumbly indistinguishable fish product with no real flavour. both dishes were also so very, very, fishy smelling-to the point of turning me off.
sadly, our entrees did not save the meal. i ordered the gnocchi with aged cheddar, described as oven baked. what i got was a small french white filled with watery sauce and overcooked gnocchi. the sauce was so thin it was like drinking broth. my guest ordered the roast chicken with bread pudding. the chicken was ok, i've had better herb flavour from lesser a place-but the bread pudding was awful. it reminded me of the box stuffing my mother used to make and she never used enough water, leaving it dry, hard and salty. inedible.
our server did notice that we barely ate any of our meals and asked about the quality. we mentioned politely that we found a few dishes too rich and perhaps the stuffing was a wee bit dry? she was sympathetic, mentioning she had heard this complaint before, but did nothing to rectify it except ask if we wanted our remaining food packaged.
on a positive note, the $18 glass of valpolicella and my $8.00 amaretto sour were lovely.
would i go back? well, i always go somewhere twice before i make up my mind but would keep in mind the $170 we spent on this disappointment. that said, i think i will go in the summer, when i can enjoy the patio and perhaps eat when a lot of the items featured on this menu are in season. until then, i reserve final judgment, although first impressions are lasting.