interesting. alloy has a nice atmosphere, though it seems loud no matter how many people are around.
food - the most important part and this is where they suffer a little. it wasn't anything bad, other than the cilantro in the tuna tartare so watch out for that, but it wasn't anything special either. plus side is the server took the tartare off the bill so that was nice.
the complimentary appy was the best part of my meal and is quite good. lots of types of olives, good hummus, and nice pita (it's not naan)
i had the pickerel and it was good, but i've had the same or better at the side of a creek in a frying pan. the sides did not really compliment the fish and did not get finished. my wife had the lamb which was excellent, but for some reason came with shredded lamb as well...weird.
for dessert we had the banana & dulche de leche banoffee pie and white peach panna cotta...they were okay at best.
wine - just like the food. nothing to write home about. i had a glass of cote du rhone which was....drinkable. the wife had a glass as well and said she could/will/would drink a whole bottle.
overall: i'd try alloy again in awhile, but there are just too many other restaurants to settle for okay food and a loud (but interesting) dining room.