don't waste your time & money. i was extremely disappointed in pawley's during my visit to columbia. i wish i had read more reviews on here before going. the entire experience, from the staff to the food was miserable.
we arrived on a saturday during lunch and had no problem with the 25-30 minute wait we were quoted. after about 45 minutes we noticed that multiple parties who had arrived after us were being seated. when we approached the hostess, she said "oh sorry! someone wrote the number for your buzzer number down wrong! it will be a few more minutes." we ended up waiting 50 minutes and watched people who had just arrived be seated before us.
we decided to start with the beer battered mushrooms we saw on the sign outside. they were completely flavorless. they were poorly fried so an exorbitant amount of oil had gotten absorbed. so we thought, hey, maybe just a bad dish, surely the burgers they are known for will be better.
we ordered the fripp island and the sullivan's, both medium with the franks redhot onion rings. both burgers were constructed with wet ingredients on the bottom, so the bun was completely soggy and useless. after cutting mine in half, i noticed it was not medium, but hardly cooked at all. it was red in the center and pink all the way to the edges, it looked to have been seared simply to make the outside brown. after waiting 15 minutes, i gave up on seeing the server again to request it be cooked more. based on the ingredients, i expected these burgers to be bursting with flavor, but they just weren't. nothing popped, nothing stood out.
i will say the onion rings were very good. they were crunchy, crisp, and well cooked. the onion inside was sweet and a perfect contrast to the salty batter. however, i did not detect any heat or spice from the hot sauce.
now i know this is minor, but they also charged more for the burgers than was listed on the menu. it was only 0.75-1.00 more, but i still feel that is dishonest. overall, the food was extremely overpriced, not very tasty, poorly cooked, and we barely saw our server. we waited 10 minutes to see him just to get some extra napkins, didn't refill our waters, and brought the wrong beer. i don't know if they have new staff since diners, drive-ins, and dives came to town. don't waste your time here, there are so many other places to go.