not all that it's cracked up to be . . .. i've been dying to go here ever since i read frank bruni's review of this place earlier this year in which he placed it in his top 10 new restaurants of 2007. that being said, i'll definitely disagree w/ his assessment . . . while the service was outstanding, the food was, overall, slightly above average. there's no way this place can be in the top 10 in this country.
i found the menu to be confused . . . are you a southwest/tex-mex inspired steakhouse as reflected by the prime rib, filet, buffalo tenderloin and elk? or are you a globally inspired hotel restaurant as reflected by your sashimi, ceviche, and new england oysters? arguably, dean fearing is trying to bridge the two together, but i think he comes up short. while some may enjoy the thought of having a wide range of food to choose from, a singular focus is sacrificed and the taste is compromised in the process.
for example, the tortilla soup (which apparently he is famous for) was way too spicy and salty, and the buffalo tenderloin, while incredibly soft, was paired with jalapeno grits that were too grainy and collard greens that were way too greasy. and the barbecue shrimp taco was one of the most pedestrian dishes i've seen on a menu of this potential caliber, and its taste certainly did nothing to change my initial assumptions . . .
there were some highlights: a surf and turf (filet w/ chicken fried lobster!) and butterscotch custard w/ mini apple fritters that almost single-handedly changed my opinion of the place. and as mentioned above, the service was incredible. our sommelier recommended an incredible hidden gem for $90 that was definitely inexpensive in a wine list full of $150-$200 wines, and our waiter and the staff all brought out our food with the standard texas charm and then some.
overall, i enjoyed it . . . but there are definitely a lot better meals to be had.