i can you hear the chants of "over-rated!". look, thisplacehas become an iconic hhi destination quite simply due to their marketing efforts and very little else. t-shirts, hats, dog collars, baby gear - you name it, they'll sell it to you. but hey, good for them.
@ the salty dog, i don't go there to eat the food to put it kindly, as there's not a lot they do different, or as good as, other places on the island. we simply go there on rare occasion to enjoy a drink or two on the outside deck. there's always a good scene with good music, good people, mostly family friendly up until late night. now, if you want to grab something fried while you're drinking - do it. but i wouldn't suggest heading there if you're looking for a great all-around meal. thisplacejust isn't built for that, any more.
have a few beers, buy a t-shirt, and get out of there!