i see what the fuss is. (the fuss is all hype).. this is one of those "vacation restaurants." people want to like things on vacation, for obvious reasons. and they do. they have the blinders on so to speak. i am on vacation too but i just want to kind of set the record straight.
1) no reservations, and they don't take names at the door. they make you stand in line around the corner. which is ok.. but it perpetuates the notion that this place is good (see they know what they are doing here...).
2) they have open tables, left uncleared-off that the line can see through the windows. again, ok but -- hire more people. we would rather wait inside at a table than stand in the line outside.
3) the famous fried chicken. yes, there is more than you can (should) eat. mine was terribly over cooked, and the meat itself was flavorless.
4) our server. the guy was personality-less, and didn't even mumble, he did less -barely spoke to us at all. visited our table 4 times at the most (including to get our drink orders and then take our order). we wanted to eat some of the famous coca cola cake, hoping to end on something that wasn't flavorless, and tasted good, but we were afraid based on our experience to this point that it would take too long.
5) wife got the friday (catholic) special (flounder) and it too was flavorless. all it tasted was fried. and there were bones in it.
6) they provide free homemade pickles. ok thanks. now pay for cornbread. wait what? a "true southern" restaurant that makes you pay for cornbread?
anyway. don't assume you are going to like this place and then give it a good review because you think you should. go somewhere new (no i don't have suggestions, i don't own any of these places).