5 out of 5 stars. the best pizza in the state, period. the wedge, humble pie, and even its own extensions can't compete. everything is delicious, but the sauce is the best part--i've never tasted its equal. a worthy adjective...ambrosial? it's extraordinarily thick and hot, fragrant, luscious... they don't skimp out on it either; i know its fashionable with good pizza to do the "european" thing and sprinkle it on in minimum amounts, buthideawayreally lets you have it. the toppings are all first-rate and tremendously fresh, more so than any pizza i've ever had. go for the hand-tossed crust for sure, other than that, you can't order wrong.
i've seen a great deal of complaints in the reviews here about misplaced orders... for the record, i've been going for over a decade and have devoured hundreds ofhideawaypies, and not once in my memory have the staff misplaced my order. many of the employees are students at the nearby college, uco, and while they are all very friendly and gregarious, i can see how the reduced amount of staff restaurant-experience might negatively affect service. however, having tried most of the pies on the menu and found them all to be scrumptious, i could personally care less if the pizza that i am served isn't exactly the same as the one i order--i know it will be delicious, and i might even find the unexpected variety to enliven the night's meal :)... not that i've ever had that happen. truly, the pizzas here are of the highest caliber--hit the link and mouse over oklahoma if you don't believe me.
http://www.foodnetwork.com/50-states-50-pizzas/package/index.html