geraldi's

absolutly wonderful food and great service! pizza was awesome!

best italian in fayetteville. massive portions for a low price. try the calzone, it's my favorite!

great homemade italian food! after eating there twice, geraldi's is quickly becoming one of my new favorite places to eat. the spaghetti with italian sausage was terrific, the pesto spaghetti was great. we topped it off with cannoli, which was scrumptious. everything is homemade and fits right in to the unassuming décor. also a great beer selection. the owner is very friendly and really enjoys socializing with the patrons. he told us about his mother, mrs.geraldi who came to america as a young girl. mr. geraldi also told us this was the 37th location he had opened (there are locations in arkansas, oregon and florida) and it's easy to see why he has been so successful. do yourself a favor and make this your next meal.

very good, pizza is great, gravy is good also.

tastes like homemade. never ending garlic bread. excellent friendly customer service. my favorite pizza in town.

great food and service! but my spaghetti noodles tasted cold. and my sauce was bland, but the meatballs are amazing!

horrible catering experience. i tried to let management know about our horrible catering event that we received from geraldi's. no one has responded.

it was so late that we had to start our even without eating. by the time the speakers finished speaking the food was cold. the intention was to have everyone get their food and eat while the speakers were speaking. obviously this didn't happen. not only was the food late and cold when we got to actually eat, but if you look at the attached photos you can see how the salad was all brown and wilted. it was disgusting to even look at. i personally could have made a better salad at home. not at all what everyone was expecting.

not only was it late and the salad wilted, but the guy that brought it was extremely rude!!!!!!!!! several associates witnessed his rude behavior. totally unacceptable in my book!!!!!!

fantastic. thoroughly enjoyed the friday prime rib special. great atmosphere. friendly staff!

ate here thursday. making reservations for saturday. need i say more? momma mias and pesto veggie pizza to die for. atmosphere not the best but with food like this who cares?

best pizza. best ny style pizza in fayetteville, however their veggie pizza is gross. (serves ya right for ordering a veggie pizza) perfect combination of a thin pizza with a light pillow crust, good sauce and a great chicken ceasar as well.

so very good. i can't express how much i like geraldi's in only a few words, but i'll try...the pizza is amazing. be sure to ask about their white bean pizza.

mmm, meatballs and cannoli.... geraldi's has to be the best new place in fayetteville in a long time. it's awesome! i've been there several times now, and it's one of my new favorites. the pizza (with meatballs) is delicious, i really enjoyed the pesto spaghetti (with meatballs) and the meatball sandwich might be the best thing i've eaten there (you might notice a trend here... the meatballs are freaking delicious!!). although the portions can make it difficult (you definitely get your money's worth), you've got to leave room for the cannoli... best desert in town, in my opinion. oh, and they have some pretty tasty garlic bread, too... seriously, eat at geraldi's!

no meat in the lasagna? just lots of pasta and tomato sauce and cheese. garlic bread was good. waitress was friendly but disappeared to answer the phone and be cashier, i gave up on getting a box or ordering anything else and had to go up front to get the check and pay.

it's hard to go elsewhere for pizza once you've had geraldi's. you won't find a bad pie on the menu and the italian desserts are a great way to round out your meal. quality ingredients make even the cheese pizza a taste explosion. don't pass this one by!

it would be great if you could bing back the chicago italian beef was the best thing there and i am from chicago so i know!