comparative review. so my wife and i decided to tackle the "big 3" brazilian steakhouses in san antonio. feel free to read my other reviews for fogo de chao and texas de brazil. this is my review ofchamagaucha with letter grades of a - f:
atmosphere: b
this place is nice, perfectly acceptable for a fancy date spot or business meeting, but it doesn't bother to compete with the opulence that is texas de brazil's interior or the intimacy of fogo's. it almost seemed sterile to me. the salad bar presentation was very neat, with employees constantly reshaping the food to make it look as if no one had touched it. i'm not sure if that's a good thing or if it just adds to the sterility. there was no doubt the place was clean, but it simply lacked personality.
service: b-
chama's service system is different than tdb's or fogo's. you do not have one main waiter. instead it seems about everyone in the restaurant stops by your table at one point or another. that would be nice if it were well timed and consistent, but it usually wasn't. we'd see five people in a 15 minute span (overkill), and then no one at all for another 15 (where's my drink?). everyone was very friendly except one grouchy gaucho. normally i tip based on the service i get, but i was confused on how to tip here. some folks were great, some not. how do you tip accordingly? i gave 15%, but had it been one individual, it would have been closer to 12%. i tip 20% for great service.
salad bar: c+
this is wherechamafalls woefully behind it's two main competitors. don't get me wrong, there's nothing wrong with the salad area, it's just much smaller with less selection and less taste than the other options in san antonio. nothing stuck out to me as excellent, nothing had me going back for more. it was just sort of...there.
meats: a-
so here's why everyone comes, right? the meat. again, realize this is a comparative review and i am stackingchamaagainst fogo and texas de brazil. that being said, the meat is great at all three places and each has their area of expertise. after sampling every meat they offered (i was able to do this since the salad bar did not entice me to eat any large portions of its unimpressive offerings) i would say chama's place to shine is their lamb. i found the beef to be better at tdb's and the pork and chicken better at fogo's. unfortunately for chama's, after sampling all three restaurants, i revisited my ultimate winner (texas de brazil) and found that perhaps the first time i ate there, they may have been having an off night with their lamb. my subsequent visit provided literally the best lamb i've ever had! so i can no longer say thatchamatops any meat category among the three. the meat atchamais good, well seasoned, and i had no complaints...but it still rates third among the three.
drinks and dessert: a-
in this reviewer's opinion, drinks are drinks, and when you're paying the premium you pay for them here they had better be good. it's hard to screw them up and none of the big 3 did. we had caipirinha's at all three, they all tasted the same, delicious! the wine selection was more limited at chama's, but we found a glass to enjoy. the dessert was nothing spectacular, but neither were they at the other two establishments. we had the key lime pie and the creme brûlée. nice, but not spectacular.
overall:b
ifchamawere the only game in town, i would visit frequently and enjoy it. i am a major foodie, though, and am constantly on the hunt for the best dining experience. so whilechamais a great eatery in its own right, when compared to fogo de chao and texas de brazil, it barely competes. should i not have started the three restaurant review process with these three restaurant in mind, i would not have even included chama's in the same category as the other two. one bright spot versus the other two is: plenty of free parking at chama's, but if you don't mind the drive downtown, skip chama's and head to fogo's or better yet, texas de brazil!