xtrodinary pizza

horrible service and atmosphere. don't take your kids in here.

no answer. called sunday evening at 7 pm 8 times- no answer- no hours posted on website- hmmmmm called new bethel ordinary and got an awesome pizza.


-----13 jul, 2014-----

disappointed. called on sunday evening at 7 pm 6 times no answer and hours are not posted! big problem- we were lookin forward to it! called the new bethel ordinary and they took care of us.

foodgazm. my and a co-worker went for the lunch pizza. place was clean, workers were nice and helpful. price was great. the pizza was amazing. i would recommend it to anyone. we came back to the office and let everyone know its great. only complaint i have is i think they should have a menu somewhere online where people can see what they are all about. we looked online before we went and couldn't find a menu anywhere. we grabbed one while we were there and brought one back.

best pizza in indy. tahey have the best pixxa in indy and other thingd on the menu are fabulous with great priced that you cant beat . after i tried their pizza they spoiled me and i love their pizza the best and dont want any others,

great pizza!!!. delicious pizza, super generous toppings!!! highly recommend!!!

joe. great food

great pizza, unreliable hours. i love the pizza here, it's got to be one of the best in the city. but it seems every time i call they either aren't open or aren't delivering. the last 4 times i've called they haven't been delivering. and the time before that it was 8:45 and they were closing up for the night. i used to order from them regularly, but haven't had their food in more than 6 months because of how unreliable the schedule is. it's a shame. i can't imagine they'll last much longer like this. i just placed my final call to them, no delivery again. i'll just stick with randy's which is just down the street. not as good of a product, but they're always there when they say they'll be.

terrible experience. ordered pizza, sandwich, breadstix, pizza was wrong, person on phone wanted to make it out like i wasnt telling the truth, called back they said they mixed it up with another persons food. said he would comp the meal then charged us for it anyway. i called back and the person in charge said he would see what he can do.... terrible experience go to the new bethel ordinary better pizza, alot better people. tell them lou sent you....

kim silva is just a lonely ol twot, with non better to do than complain about pizza that is crazy f'n good! owners care about the quality and insane size of their always great pizzas..! i liked it at nbo and now even better at xtraordinary!!!

i live the food, it is amazing...they always get our order right and the prices are reasonable. last week the delivery driver was rude and came without change. first bad experience with them so i figured i would give them a pass and ordered this week. come to find out, it was the owner that delivered to me the week before. kinda makes me a little upset that i was treated like that by the actual owner. ill give them one more chance because like i said they are amazing, but kinda put a bad taste in my mouth now.

big pizza!. i like all types of pizza. this type of pizza is the "very heavy on the toppings" pizza that focuses on a quantity of toppings rather than the crust or sauce (what i call "bar pizza"). i had a 16" with sausage, ham, pepperoni, onions, green peppers, mushrooms and jalepenos. the sauce was adequate both in quantity and taste but did not taste like it was made in house. the crust was very plain and didn't taste like it was fresh made. the toppings, especially the meat, are very plentiful. personally, i would like fresh mushrooms but these tasted canned. however, the overall mix of flavors was pretty good and i enjoyed the pizza. the jalepenos, though canned, were pretty crisp and had a lot of pop. this pizza would definitely satisfy some hearty appetites as it weighed about 10 pounds. they cut into 8 pieces so if you have many eaters, you may want to have it cut into more pieces.

i would say this pizza was better than the last one i had from the ordinary, which wasn't very good.

my favorite pizza still remains bazbeaux on mass ave.

update: since my original review i've had a pizza from gallaghers and another pizza from xtrodinary. the xtrodinary pizza was clearly better.

southeast of indianapolis is wanamaker.it’s a community,founded in 1836, that has the charm and appeal of a small town. that is where we decided to have our grand adventure. first stop was wanamaker guns. it’s a small shop in a mini strip mall . they have a great inventory of old guns. black powder long guns , old springfield rifles and  hand guns ;and a  plethora of military related models. they also have a nice supply of accessories. as a matter of fact i got a sweet deal on an uncle mikes holster; 6 bucks less than current list price. the reason we stopped there first was that it was on the way to xtraordinary  pizza. the first thing i noticed about the place was the tableau right next door. it was a little wooden shack covered with old metal signs complete with a gas pump and an old tow truck . it even had its own intersection, with street signs and a dog ‘n’ suds drive in sign. my pictures of the little scene don’t even come close to doing it justice. inside it looked the way a sm

great pizza, great value. lots of pizza. our family of 4, with 2 teenage boys, can only eat 1 piece at a time, very large and filling and delicious. we always order for dinner and have enough for for lunch the next day. this is not your thin, skimpy, new york style pizza, this is a fork and knife pizza with lots of toppings.

crazy good. simply put, this is great pizza for a great price! anyone who says otherwise must be a disgruntled, yet loyal, new bethel ordinary patron.

bad pizz. upon delivery the pizzas were cold. not enough sauce on one of the large pizzas was skimpy on the sauce making the pizza dry. overall, i would give this place a 3. very poor. i won't order from this place again.