update (august, 2017): a much, much better experience as of late. great service, and the breakfast sampler was spot-on (three eggs over-easy, crispy home fries, a quality piece of country ham and solid biscuits and gravy).
for me, this place is a prime example of a popular lexington institution that is resting on its reputation and not churning out quality dishes. i knowwinchell'shas a strong following here in town, but i have visited this restaurant twice in recent months, and was disappointed both times.
my wife and i came here for sunday brunch, and the coffee tasted old and bitter. my wife ordered the biscuit and gravy plate, with bacon, and i ordered the breakfast sampler (eggs over easy, bacon, toast). as my wife described it, our breakfast reminded her of a middle school cafeteria, where the cafeteria workers were more friendly than our server.
i later visitedwinchell'sfor lunch and i ordered the blt sandwich (on wheat toast), served with house chips - the sandwich and the chips were average. if i am looking for a diner in town, i am going to suggins.