a new, dedicated follower. as a recent north carolina transplant, i had my deep-dish cherry popped at original gino’s east – and i’ve been honest and true to the superior street restaurant ever since.
i’m embarrassed to say the wife and i had lived in chicago for over four months before striking out to try our first deep-dish pie. rumors of chewy bread-like crusts and soggy samplings kept us away, so it took my brother coming into town before we wandered over from streeterville to give them the chance.
we stood outside for about 20 minutes on a busy friday evening around 5:00pm – we had showed up early with hopes of getting a table...seems most of chicago was thinking the same thing.
once we were seated upstairs, we were surrounded by graffiti-covered walls, featuring names, initials and declarations of past loves, all in white paint, chalk and markers. just a heads’ up: the place is dark. deepest, darkest-of-caves dark. we found ourselves passing the candle around the table as each of us tried to read the menu.
first rule of any deep-dish; pack a lunch if you arrive hungry. these monsters take a solid 30-45 minutes to show up tableside once you’ve ordered – our server let us know, in advance, to expect the wait.
on our most recent outing, we ordered a medium chicago firehouse, featuring a hot-and-spicy bottom of patty-style sausage, fire roasted red peppers and thin slices of red onions.
first and foremost, and despite our preconceived fears, these deep-dish pies are not loaves of bread covered in runny tomatosauce– the crust was amazingly flaky and tender, and just thick enough to hold the massive layer of toppings. the sauce-to-topping ratio was perfect, and the cheese was distinctive and had a great pull. the firehouse’s sausage certainly brings a little heat to the party and has become our favorite.
while a medium is certainly enough for two people – you’ll probably end up taking two to three slices home anyway. and at $25 for a medium pie of six slices, it’s definitely turns in to a two night dining experience .... re-heated, these pizzas are just as good as they were table side.
yes, we're eaten around the corner at "that other guy's place', but we keep coming back to gino's east for the fun atmosphere, awesome pies and superior service.
enjoy!