4.5 stars (this site doesn't allow half-stars) primarily losing half of one on the long wait that was longer than stated and the use of patrón in your upper-end tequilas.
ok, new mexican cuisine is truly a bit of an outlier for me in thefoodworld, having grown up in west texas and steeped in the rich, varied tex-mex and mexican cuisines of that region. that being said, my limited experience with new mexican cuisine in las cruces and in santa fe would clearly put the shed up against any mexican restaurant of any type in the united states. the expression of the red chile is bountiful and consummate here.
as if it needs any more stars from one more reviewer due to its james beard award it won in 2003, this place is marvelous. here goes:
1. the margaritas offered are really tasty. the menu almost looks trite with the many variations they offer off of their base margarita, but the st. rita (elderberry being the added in this one) was quite marvelous. the other margarita, the elite silver, was really tasty (use herradura -- it's better).
2. the chile con queso (basic in the mexican cuisine world, yes, but rather tasty) has marvelous green chiles that make it truly a more-than-one-chip offering. even the kids cleared the bowls.
3. carne adovada [sic] in most places is overcooked and has been sitting in a pot for ages. this was marvelously delicious with red chiles setting off further taste buds, and the enchilada on the plate and the hominy side were simply divine. truly unique.
4. the desserts were fine, but i left with fond memories of red-chile-immersed fairies dancing on my tongue.
this is a must for all to visit in santa fe. the end.