good food - consistently. negatives - (a) waaaaaaay over in new haven ;) , (b) the smoke, even though there are "smoke eaters" , at times can be overwhelming, and (c) quite crowded at times, leading to difficulties in finding seating and/or longer waits on the food delivery.
positives - (a) well, since they are that crowded, shows just how good they are!, (b) food is quite good, (c) service is always with a smile, (d) prices are reasonable, and (e) decor is enjoyable, pleasant wood surroundings, comfortable.
update - august 20, 2010 - two of my favorites continue to be the sausage rolls [add ham, bacon, and chicken to it to create a 'special'] and the pulled pork sandwich [the 1 pound version - yea, iloveleftovers ;) ]. the chips and salsa, for a place that is not a mexican restaurant per se, are both quite tasty. and, you will not go thirsty here - example, today's lunch wait staff brought over 3 cherry cokes, each time a new one just as the previous one was not even 1/2 empty - the last one put into a go cup. good food, good service.