so here we are, the crowning jewel in auckland suburban dining in epsom.
it’s a midweek dinner in what is known to be one of auckland’s finer dining experiences, this is not the norm for us, nor is it a special occasion. a work colleague was heading overseas on holiday and had a $50 voucher to onetreegrill and didn’t want to see it go to waste, thanks karen!
onetreegrill is constantly brought up in conversation and magazine articles as one of the top 10 restaurants in auckland, i can tell you from one glimpse of the menu that they’re prices are certainly in the top 10, now, let’s see if the experience can match …
their entrees are priced from $26+ and the mains are $42+. this pricing immediately puts them in the same company as the french café, the grove, clooney and sidart.
at this price point, there are two main types of service you can experience while dining out, warm, smiling, almost loving service that makes you feel like you could never overstay your welcome. or the accommodating professional, to the point, no fuss, efficient and stealth like, ensuring the evening flows flawlessly without you really ever knowing they’re there. and just sometimes on those rare occasions, you get the perfect mixture of the 2. onetreegrill this night provided us with neither, plane waiters going about their plane jobs, no fuss, certainly not a complaint, just nothing that was memorable.
the menu’s arrive in the form of ipad’s ….. not a review or conversation goes by on onetreegrill where this does not get mentioned, quite the talking point, and i take it they like it that way. for me, this schtick emphasises the confusion in this restaurant. it doesn’t match the ambience or the style of the place. if people are talking more about the medium that the menu’s are delivered rather than the food/service, that’s a concern for me.
lastly, the food.
the seared scallops were roll your eyes to the back of your head yummy, blissful eating.
the lamb belly entrée has a lovely sear and with the garden peas to accompany, made for the perfect winter entree.
it is once in a blue moon i order steak at a restaurant. the black angus rib eye was cooked to perfection, for $48, i would expect nothing less …. but …. i would expect a little bit more, as that’s all my $48 got me, a 450g piece of meat cooked mr.
the other main was the duck, with celeriac, baby beets, mandarin and pine nuts, all condiments gelled superbly, really well balanced, the let down here being that the fat under the duck skin hadn’t been rendered down properly, a slimy, chewy layer of fat with every bite.
i have eaten at clooney, the grove and sidart and am booked into the french café in a couple of weeks, before sid gets his hands on it.
i don’t say this to gloat, no, i say it so i can legitimately compare onetreegrill to similarly priced restaurants. and my conclusion is that it doesn’t stand up next to the other power players of the auckland food scene. after eating at those other establishments i felt like i had just been treated, i felt spoiled, at some point during the meal, there was a wow factor. walking away from onetreegrill i kind of felt like i’d been had, like they saw me coming.
maybe i’m missing something about this place … maybe i don’t get it? am i missing the wow factor?