somewhat similar to earl's, slightly more chain-y, but with a larger menu. service was very friendly and i can't complain about that. the menu touches on a few different things, but at its most adventurous it's americanized versions of ethnic dishes which is probably to be expected considering the market they're trying to sell to.
i had the steak sandwich and was pleased that they decided to do something a little different with it, opting for a slightly spicy, tangy sauce on the bread and decent vegetables instead of falling back to the garlic-based classical version. made it interesting, worked well, and distracted me (for a while) from the average quality steak itself. i was disappointed at the serving size though, with only a smallish side of fries, i wasn't exactly full by the end of my meal. the prices themselves aren't awfully high, they have a lot of dishes in the mid-price range of $14-19 that seems to be the market price in saskatoon, but the serving size was definitely smaller than competitors selling at similar prices. without a second side on these dishes (ala original joe's) they are on the lower end of the value spectrum.
ambience is a pretty subjective thing but i'm going to rate it anyway since it affected my experience. the place is so damn loud inside, at least where we sat. they have very nice 18-ish foot ceilings, but no sound dampening, so the cacophony of voices and crying babies are bouncing off the walls and carrying further than they should. i felt like we both had to yell to sustain a conversation. the decor and style of the place tries a bit too hard to be trendy but is too spartan to be genuine, so i think that's where people get the 'pretentious' label from. i think that's just part of themoxie'sbrand, i remember it being the same way when i last ate here as a child.
anyway, not for everyone, but a solid choice if upper-end american chain cuisine is in your wheelhouse. seems like the creativity put into the dishes is above average so we'll probably be back to take another swing at that.