bistro gitan


İçinde "staff" olan yorumlar
4
3.7
bansheebeat
5
2 yıl önce
south yarra
i honestly refuse to believe that anyone would write a bad review of bistro gitan. thestaffare warm & friendly, the food is absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is wonderful. easily in my top favourite spots in melbourne.


-----25 may, 2012-----

a fantastic dining experience!. i would gladly come back here again and again. went with 5 people and tried all different menu items and everything was superb. i had the escargots, home town hapuka, pear tart and left there incredibly content. wine selection was excellent, many great liqueurs available and the coffee was perfect. service was amazing and atmosphere was very warm and friendly whilst being quite a fancy dining experience. would happily recommend to a french food lover. you will not be disappointed!!
0
sue
2
2 yıl önce
south yarra
poor service. food and general setting good but the waiter slopped coffee in the saucer, knew he had done it but did not return with anything to assist with the slop. just a general lack of charm and care fromstaffmade it anything but french, however the food was good. not sure, given the wealth of great restaurants in the area i would return.
0
marmadook
5
2 yıl önce
south yarra
went here for my birthday celebration and couldn't have asked for a better night. the waitstaffwere amongst the best i've ever experienced! we ordered extensively from the menu, the pate was a stand out. it was nice to see the spatchcock cooked correctly, still pink, the way it should be. perfect!
0
apb
2
2 yıl önce
south yarra
a 'memorable' night. the evening commenced with the waitress assessing our table of four as consisting of village idiots. when the unpalatably salty fresh oysters were returned we were told the cheff thought that they were fine. we are not sure why we were told this. the spatchcock was served undercooked, and left unfinished as we were too intimidated by the waitress to complain, and also because we were, in any case, still trying to preserve the vestiges of a pleasant evening. we were charged an extra $3.50 for a single oyster which had been eaten from the returned half dozen, until we complained. a mean spirited attitude. when they threw the bill on the table, the evening was sealed. if you enjoy very ordinary meals served with more than a dash of arrogance, this is the place for you. we did retrieve something of the evening when standing outside, astaffmember approached us to further deal with our complaints to receive a firm but civil response from the victim of the raw spatchcock, who now outside the lion's den and recharged by the bracing air advised, amongst a nicely reasoned set of propositions: "we are not village idiots ... we're professionals, you know". which had little do with the meal, the service or much else, but gave us a good laugh.
0
happy
5
2 yıl önce
south yarra
lovely lunch. i recently popped in to bistro gitan in south yarra and was rewarded with the most delightful lunch. thestaffwere so welcoming and inviting (and good looking!). i had the menu du jour that comprised a crispy quail salad (salade belge) with spicy lentil soup for just $23. it was all so delicious, i even indulged in a coffee creme brûlée for dessert. i have since bought friends back and it is all our new favourite restaurant.
0
imelda
2 yıl önce
south yarra
naughty children. we had our first and probably our only meal at bistro gatin last night. the waitress was huffy and brusque and was not amused that someone at our table found the oysters very salty. as a treat he had ordered a dozen, which were served on two plates...oops! when he complained, she was not happy. she agreed to take the secong half dozen off the bill, but when the account arrived they had charged for one of the final six that was eaten.... a little petty. we challenged this and they did take $3.50 off the account .

i had the spatchcock, which i found to be very red near the bone. being a coward, i said nothing and ate the cooked bits, but when we were leaving left a note on the table. one of thestafffollowed us outside having read the note and to his credit said i should have spoken up - and he is right, but even though we are all middle aged and 'professional' we did not feel thestaffnecessarily had our comfort and enjoyment at heart.

this is not a cheap restaurant, and even though complimentary bread was served, when more butter was asked for - and one lonely piece of bread left - no more bread was offered. a small detail, however our overall impression was not of generosity and service, but of irritation and meanness.
0
hannah
1
2 yıl önce
south yarra
when my father contracted food poisoning here last week and became extremely ill for 48 hours post dining he contacted the manager here out of courtesy so they could make sure no one else suffered similarly. 
treatment of the complaint was appalling, he was sent an 'accidental' message from the manager calling him a con artist and did not so much as receive an apology from the restaurant.
from a family that has dined here frequently over many years we will not be returning. we have seen the service and food slipping for some time now and will not be returning.
value for money is sub par, the food just average and with our most recent experience with theirstaffservice is literally appalling.
i would urge management to review their handling of complaints, especially one as serious as food poisoning from a loyal customer of many years.
0
james
5
2 yıl önce
south yarra
utterly amazing! 10/10. from the moment we walked in the scene was set, the look and feel was so amazingly staged, it felt like a close friends home immediately and we were encapsulated in the mood from then on. we were warmly greeted by a waiter straight away and had our winter coat's taken from us and then sat down at our table. the selection of great wines was so vast that we had to sip water for quite a few minutes while we decided! we proceeded to order our food and wine and before we knew it, the entree was served, we had a selection of dishes which we shared and they were all simply sublime, in both taste and appeal. now i'm not sure of the time between our entree and mains but, it was perfect, we seemed to get lost in the charming atmosphere and affability and before we knew it, the next course arrived just as the hunger bells were ringing. i can't say a bad word about our evening at bistro gitan, the mains were majestic and delicious (once again the 4 of us shared), and how can anyone complain about the price when meals are basically at pub bistro prices!!!
congratulations to thestaffand chef, you're doing an excellent job! i will be back time and time again.
0
indra
4
2 yıl önce
south yarra
food was mostly delicious (gnocchi, parfait and punkpin were outstanding) with some exceptions (spatchock and mushroom croquettes). real letdown was the service, while most of thestaffwere lovely one person in particular was very rude and seemed to think it was a massive inconvenience that we decided to share plates. they also forgot to bring 3 dishes out.
0
two
3
5 yıl önce
south yarra
3.4. very nice place. atmosphere was good, food was good, drinks were good, service was good. all with one significant exception which i’ll cover shortly.

i was greeted cheerily on arrival. we all were. staffattentiveness and efficiency was good and we all got our drinks and meals in good time. things were humming along nicely. i had the scallops for entree and that was a lovely dish. the scallops were plump, juicy and flavoursome. it was a lovely start.

our table was very efficiently advised by our server that there was only one of one of the specials - veal with brussel sprouts etc - still available. much to the disappointment of a couple of our party, i snapped it up immediately as it sounded delicious. anyway, the dish came and i started it and then realised there were no sprouts. i’m a brussel sprouts nut. i enquired where they were and was told they’d run out. i was disappointed but fine about that happening. what i wasn’t happy about at all was that no one actually informed me of the exclusion of a key ingredient from the dish. i was even more surprised that i actually had to ask for something else as some sort of compensation. i asked if another vegetable could be provided and eventually was offered a small portion of braised cabbage which was very nice.

anyway, i’m a pretty calm and affable soul normally and was throughout this matter but it did annoy me intensely. basically, what happened made no sense in a customer or commercial sense. first, if the vegetable highlighted in the meal description isn’t available, just say so and let the customer know. don’t assume that they won’t notice the omission of a key element of the dish. it’s sort of insulting or at least unthinking. second, offer something else immediately, especially if you’re caught out as they were here. how much does it take to offer a substitute vegetable. a couple of dollars? why did i have to ask for something else when i’m paying serious money not just for this dish but for the overall meal. i was surprised. this is a very good restaurant and matter was handed poorly. the dish was lovely but it didn’t have one of the key things i wanted in it. in the end i was actually made to look like the awkward one for pressing for a substitute vegetable. that’s not good enough.

the matter caused problems for the table. two of my companions thought i’d done the right thing calling the matter out and asking for something else. my other companion would have preferred i let it go. i won on the numbers 3-1 and probably won on entertainment value too. but, i would have preferred the matter hadn’t arisen at all. i wanted to talk to my friends about anything other than the inactions of the restaurant.

my dessert was a citrus slice of some kind with a citrus sorbet. i should have been concentrating a little more but wasn’t. all i recall is that the dish was very nice. it was a lovely dessert.

we enjoyed our meals overall. they were generally high quality. service was generally very good, except for the matter mentioned, especially from jade. it is a very nice restaurant to while away the time as well.

we had a couple of rieslings and a pinot noir through the night from the very good wine list. the aussie riesling trumped the alsace riesling. seriously bone dry beats dry. we finished the night with dirty martinis which were nuclear strong and exceptionally good. we were advised that they were the strongest in the city. they’re certainly the strongest i’ve ever had. they were exceptional.

it was a very nice but not inexpensive night overall. this is a good restaurant except in respect of the incident mentioned above. i am still pining for those missing sprouts.
0
jenny
5
6 yıl önce
south yarra
we’ve been a few times and it never disappoints, the service, ambiance and food is always great, thestaffare always very attentive, fair value for money too
0
krishna
4
6 yıl önce
south yarra
wow what a lovely experience, we decided to come here for our 10th anniversary and everything was delicious, attentivestaffwho ensured that we moved tables when a very young family arrived. oysters, scallops, spatchcock, blue eye trevally, steamed greens, rose water brûlée, nebbiolo, pinot noir, lillet rose and vin de noix $230
0
kate
2
7 yıl önce
south yarra
this was a bizarre restaurant experience. was excited to try bistro gitan, as i am a big fan of bistro thierry and france soir...however, was massively let down by the food. the oysters and parfait we had for entree were delicious but that was the extent of the delicious food. 

we tried the prawn cocktail, which came with the strange combination of prawns smeared with mayonnaise and ketchup, as well as a single slice of avocado and grapefruit/mandarin segments. the flavour combination did not work well together and the dish looked like it had been thrown on the plate.

we then tried the king fish ceviche special. the cut of fish was  thick and chewy and the sauce tasted like it had separated. this dish could work if the flavours were balanced better. finally, we tried the garfish. it came as a deep fried piece of fish with plain side salad. for $35, it shouldn't taste like it could be purchased from the local fish and chip shop. 

overall, i couldn't believe that this restaurant has the reviews it has or was busy as it was. maybe we came on an off night? however, given the small size of bistro gitan's menu, they should be cooking everything perfectly. 

i never post bad reviews, but thought that this one was necessary!staffwere friendly and attentive though.
0
s
3
7 yıl önce
south yarra
overall the experience was average. nothing special that would make me want to go back. the food was okay. the service was good.staffwere friendly and attentive. not many choices. the restaurant looked old. ambience and vibe were pretty average.
0
andrew
4
7 yıl önce
south yarra
firstly the setting is amazing, tucked away and not in the heart of any main eatery strip. the building is warmly lit and the decor inside is everything you would hope for in a french bistro. thestaffare very attentive and willing to help as soon as you open the door. we organised a small birthday party and they could not have been more helpful. there is a small bar in the middle to enjoy a couple of drinks before your meal. the menu here is typical french bistro style with a gypsy twist. flavourful, warming and delicious,
0
oturum aç
hesap oluştur