ok, i don’t know whether this is an unpopular opinion or one of those unspoken ones. probably it’s just our luck but let just say we were disappointed with ourexperienceat amaru. i’ve always wanted to come here after hearing so many ‘food critics’ rave about it, so we were so excited to come here to celebrate a special occasion. we got the sensory menu which includes all of their signature dishes.
.
let’s start on a positive note, staff were presentable and deserve applause for friendly and efficient service. we received our starter not long after ordering, it was actually served very quickly, which isn’t necessarily a bad thing in fine dining as you don’t have to wait half an hour for a single dish. my favourite starter was the smoked duck ham, love that subtle smokey flavour. smoked eel was slightly crisp and creamy with the eel’s seafoodness. i found the dim sim quite ordinary, and the garfish a bit salty. they didn't get off to a strong start for us.
.
here comes the disaster, the mussels with charred broccoli & grilled lettuce was extremely salty 🤢, even my partner with savoury tongue could not handle it, turns out they did over-season the soup. we get it, chefs make mistakes too. but it really left a persistent salty taste for us. mud crab 🦀 with iced apple did help wash out that salty taste on our tongue, it was refreshing and had a decent amount of crab meats. right after that, their sourdough with tasmanian goat butter if i recall correctly and balsamic honey. the crust of my sourdough was a bit too hard and thick for my liking, the butter was nice but not the best one i’ve had. the pastrami brined quail with dried peach, again a bit salty. maybe that’s what it supposed to taste like 🤷🏻♂️!? no real wow factor. lamb sweetbreads & sweetcorn with freshly shaved italian truffle ($45 extra over two dishes) the broth was clean and tasty, generously covered with truffle, makes it extra fragrance. the stand out savoury dish has to be the red kangaroo, cooked perfectly between rare to medium rare.
.
their desserts are winners to me, start with strawberry sorbet 🍓was delightful, you can taste there were real strawberries in it. mixed it with citrus curd and frozen pistachio marshmallow, mmmmm it was so good! the otway shiitake ice cream 🍄 with shiso and cacao, topped with fresh truffle was absolutely to die for. that’s the wow factor i was looking for, one of the best ice cream i’ve ever had 😋. last but not least, the exquisite salted woodside goat curd🐐🧀 was actually a golden goat’s cheese cheesecake. the presentation was stylish and instagramable. flavors were distinct and creamy, with a soft, almost spreadable texture. my absolute favourite of the night.
.
we ended our meal with olive oil pastille & pumpkin caramel which were quite a unique treat. overall i would give this place 3.5 ratings, it just didn’t meet my sky-high expectations (rated 4.9/5 on zomato). you would expect an incredibly innovative meal from an ex vue de monde sous chef but it was just satisfactory. if i am paying $195 for a meal, i expect the food to be perfect and unforgettable. such a shame as i really wanted to love this place, lovely staff but unfortunately we’re very unlikely to come back.